I'm not completely satisfied. I thought I was getting an insole similar to the ones in my leather ptc oxfords. These don't compare. My foot slides back and forth each step I take, so they are definitely not what I needed. This is very annoying, being I don't feel grounded. I did explain to Celia whom suggested these that I wanted replacement insoles for the leather ptc oxfords and she suggested these to me. They are not what I expected at all. I'd much rather the original insoles that came in my leather ptc oxfords for the price I paid. This is my second pair of leather ptc oxfords, and I noticed within 4 -6 months my insoles are shot! They don't last at all. As for the shoe itself, I absolutely love them. They are sturdy, durable and well made. The insoles not so.